When Your Life Hangs In The Balance.


Mumbai, 11th December 2014.

Even before I begin with this rather heated topic, I’d like to clearly state that over here by presenting the following post to you’ll I’m under no circumstances being unfair to any medical professional or rather the medical fraternity as a whole. I’m by means of the post which is to follow trying to generate awareness about such practices which are getting highly prevalent in modern developed, under-developed as well as undeveloped countries. My intention here is not to blame all the medical professionals but a percent of them due to which people are losing trust in doctors. Over here I’m to tell about that strata of the medical fraternity who take patients as their business, my intention is not to hurt the emotions of people who are connected to the medical background but to get people aware of what I, myself have witnessed as cases of sheer medical negligence. I’m sure the medical fraternity is working wonders for people, apart from that one percent who are making it worse.


How could I ever forget the frightful night of 9th December, 2014. I had finished my semester exams that afternoon, and had been resting all day later finally breathing a sense of relief. My phone rang and read “Seema Gandhi”, who happens to be my neighbor and a close friend in need, I was appalled, never had she called me at that point of time in the night, provided it wasn’t an emergency. I picked up and to my dismay she was wailing and weeping rather badly, I asked her what the matter was.. She told me, ” Hardii… Kevin’s father has got a massive heart attack, and we’re in **** nursing home, Please you’ll come here..” and the disconnected the call. It came as a shock because that day itself her husband had returned from his business tour, had been for an outing with their toddler and upon returning this happened. Nevertheless we rushed to nursing home, it was upsetting seeing her mourning for her husband because they had a five year old baby boy, she being just 32, but from a very rural and undeveloped village of India, her husband, being the only earning member is about 50 years of age. she can not speak or understand general English, and had been tensed since there was no future of their baby without her husband.

Upon asking the nurse as to where the doctor was, she began by saying that, “Doctor will be coming in the next 20 minutes”, again shocked as we were, because there had to be a doctor on duty, the patient needed immediate medical assistance, he could’ve suffered badly had it not been the doctor of Seven Hills Hospital Mumbai. Upon asking the doctor at the nursing home as to how the patient was now, the Doctor replied that he was critical and had to spent at least four days out there, we felt something fishy, also Since it was a small nursing home with no better facilities at availability, we decided to shift him to another hospital which though far, had a good reputation at its honor.Upon knowing that we have called an ambulance along with a doctor from Seven Hills Hospital, the doctor at the nursing home had a different story to offer all together. He said, “Why did you’ll call another doctor? I mean we can discharge him by tomorrow, he’s all good and in a good state now.” It was something extremely weird, the doctor was changing colors all too soon. In about 20 minutes an ambulance from Seven Hills arrived and the doctor rushed inside to check the patient. He then had a heated argument with the doctor of the nursing home because he had not provided any treatment yet. A patient who just got a massive heart attack had not been treated since the past hour. The doctor didn’t seem to have a logical explanation as to why had the right treatment not been given. Without wasting much of time, we shifted to Seven Hills, at about 1:00 in the night. Quick action was taken over there, doctors were ready, the patient was treated by Dr. Madhusudan Yemel, nurses were all very supportive, and within an hour the right treatment had been given, with minimal charges.

Now, by stating the above case which I’ve witnessed with my own eyes, I’m meaning to convey the message of medical negligence or medical malpractice. “Medical malpractice is professional negligence by act or omission by a health care provider in which the treatment provided falls below the accepted standard of practice in the medical community and causes injury or death to the patient, with most cases involving medical error.”


Now, I think my title is very much justified, The patient’s life surely does hang in the balance, We’re dependent on the doctor’s to save our respective lives and some of them are proving us wrong. In India, lacks and lacks of such cases take place every year, wherein the patient dies either because the doctor wasn’t available at the hospital or because he’s prescribed a wrong medication or many many more such reasons to be counted. Sometimes it happens also due to negligence of nurses. To cite my own case, when my mother had been pregnant, there were some complications and hence some injection had to be given to her, amount of which was to be 0.1, the nurse in negligence gave it as 1.0. As a result, my mother went into coma, only waking up after seven hours. I hope everyone understands how dangerous it is for someone to slip into coma. Something like this cannot be taken for granted, I totally understand that humans make mistakes but this was more. These days doctors are doing it as a business, of earning more money, wherein if the patient would stay in the hospital for more days, and hence it being profitable to the hospitals and fellow nursing homes. Hospitals and nursing homes are now signing contracts wherein it’s a deal between the doctor and them that if the doctor gets a patient he gets X amount of money, if the doctor is successful in keeping the patient for more than 2 days, he gets Y amount of money. Like, what was that? They think it’s something good? hell no. Many people are aware of this racket but few have the guts to stand up against this. Why? why are people this weak ? when it comes to gossiping about what a certain person went through and what wrong had been practiced with that person, everyone takes an active part, but when asked to take action against such malpractices no one is at hand.

My uncle who owns a recognized laboratory, was discussing with me that now on a trend has taken over, that being of the labs providing reports to patients of whatever the doctor says. Simply amazing.! I’m happy that at least there are various laws in India against such crimes.  Fortunately, doctors, nurses, and hospitals make mistakes in a small number of cases. But within that small minority of cases, certain types of errors crop up more often than others.


There are many different ways you or someone you know can be seriously injured as a result of medical malpractice. The following are several examples of the ways an individual can die or be seriously injured due to medical malpractice:

  • Bacterial infections
  • Birth injury
  • Chiropractic malpractice
  • Dental malpractice
  • Diagnosis error
  • Dental malpractice
  • Emergency room errors
  • Elder abuse / nursing home neglect
  • Gastric bypass errors
  • Medication errors
  • Nursing negligence
  • Pharmacy errors
  • Surgical malpractice
  • Wrongful death.

With the awareness in the society and the people in general gathering consciousness about their rights, measures for damages in tort, civil suits and criminal proceedings are on the augment. Not only civil suits are filed, the accessibility of a medium for grievance redress under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (CPA), having jurisdiction to hear complaints against medical professionals for deficiency in service, has given rise to a large number of complaints against doctors, being filed by the persons feeling aggrieved. The criminal complaints are being filed against doctors alleging commission of offenses punishable under Sec. 304A or Sections 336/337/338 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) alleging rashness or negligence on the part of the doctors resulting in loss of life or injury of varying degree to the patient. This has given rise to a situation of great distrust and fear among the medical profession and a legal assurance, ensuring protection from unnecessary and arbitrary complaints, is the need of the hour. The liability of medical professionals must be clearly demarcated so that they can perform their benevolent duties without any fear of legal sword. At the same time, justice must be done to the victims of medical negligence and a punitive sting must be adopted in deserving cases. This is more so when the most sacrosanct right to life or personal liberty is at stake.

A medical practitioner cannot be held liable simply because things went wrong from mischance or misadventure or through an error of judgment in choosing one reasonable course of treatment in preference of another. A medical practitioner would be liable only where his conduct fell below that of the standards of a reasonably competent practitioner in his field. At least three weighty considerations can be pointed out which any forum trying the issue of medical negligence in any jurisdiction must keep in mind. These are: (i) that legal and disciplinary procedures should be properly founded on firm, moral and scientific grounds; (ii) that patients will be better served if the real causes of harm are properly identified and appropriately acted upon; and (iii) that many incidents involve a contribution from more than one person, and the tendency is to blame the last identifiable element in the chain of causation the person holding the ‘smoking gun’. Thus, to establish a medical negligence, the above mentioned position must be kept in mind.


Don’t fall prey to such professionals who are hungry simply for money, know to practice your rights, at the right time and in the best possible manner.


This blog is owned and maintained by Hardi Goradia.

The content on this site is offered only as a public service to the web community and does not constitute solicitation or provision of legal advice.  This site should not be used as a substitute for obtaining legal advice from an attorney licensed or authorized to practice in your jurisdiction. You should always consult a suitably qualified attorney regarding any specific legal problem or matter. The comments and opinions expressed on this site are of the individual author and may not reflect the opinions of the firm or any individual attorney.

Nothing on this site is intended to create an attorney-client relationship and nothing posted constitutes legal advice. Neither the transmission of the information contained on this site nor your use of the information or communication with Hardi, creates an attorney-client relationship between you and Hardi. No information communicated to Hardi, through this site will be protected by either the attorney-client privilege or the work product doctrine.

This website does not provide legal advice of any kind, and we cannot guarantee that the information is accurate, complete or up-to-date. Given the nature of and speed with which online communications are developed, the opinions and thoughts posted to this site are of a casual nature and may change after further reflection. While we intend to make every attempt to keep the information on this site current, the owners of and contributors to this site make no claims, promises or guarantees about the accuracy, completeness or adequacy of the information contained in or linked to from this site.

Since legal advice must be tailored to the specific circumstances of each case, and laws are constantly changing, nothing on this site should be used as a substitute for the advice of competent legal counsel. The author, Hardi Goradia assumes no responsibility to any person who relies on information contained on this site and disclaim all liability in respect to such information. You should not act upon information in this website without seeking professional counsel from an attorney admitted or authorized to practice in your jurisdiction.

The author of the content of this site are only authorized to practice law in the jurisdictions in which they are properly licensed. For more information, please contact the authors. Unless otherwise indicated, the attorneys listed on this website are not certified by any state’s or jurisdiction’s board of legal specialization; nor certified as an “expert” or “specialist” pursuant to any authority governing the practice of law.

125 thoughts on “When Your Life Hangs In The Balance.

  1. well I only had time to skim this – but I will be back – this is scary – but I know it is true stuff – and well, I can’t wait to finish reading – wow –

    Liked by 2 people

  2. You are well on your way to being a solicitor; keep reading, writing and learn legal procedure: most cases fall because of procedural defects. Legal malpractice also occurs; it seems all the professions have gained an inordinate number of scammers. Keep thinking (my boss used to say “you gotta think good; then do”)

    Liked by 3 people

  3. We must learn to be our own advocate. Sadly, there is a divide between patient and doctor. Some doctors, not all, believe they hold a superiority over their patients. They sadly assume they are above their client and therefore lies a great part of the problem.

    We must also understand that all of us are humans, nowhere perfect and thus must accept human error from time to time. But blatant, delayed or ignored care should be considered and treated as criminal.

    Thank you so much for your article. I feel your rage and respect it sincerely.

    Liked by 2 people

      1. And this is exactly why we need to teach one another the value of our words and concerns. When we are dissatisfied with their behavior we must challenge it in a pro-active manner. Offer our concerns respectfully and allow them to do likewise. If that fails, take our concerns to their peer group. Should that not result in addressing a concern, go to their superior(s). We must keep our wits about ourselves and expect them to rise to the occasion. Three separate times I have had to raise concerns, twice the problems were openly discussed between myself and my doctors. Only once did I need to reach out to The Red Cross. That issue was acknowledged and also rectified.

        In defense of some doctors, they are simply smothered in paperwork over here in the United States. Demanded to do more, with less, by insurance companies, and a Government with a political move toward socializing a system under archaic means, we, the patient, are left with only our voice. We must learn to use it affectively and never discount it’s power.

        Again, I thank you for this very insightful and thought provoking piece.

        Liked by 3 people

  4. As a non medical background practitioner I was asked to return to Australia from Asia to reengineer one of the top private hospitals which was in trouble financially. It was a big one with 2,500 employees and 560 doctors. They wanted someone who had no bias and could be impartial in dealing with the problems. As there was an excellent accreditation program already in practice for doctors and nurses who wanted to attach to the hospital and a peer review committee to look into any claims against doctor negligence I did not have to worry about that. In addition to that all disputes between patients and doctors need to be reported and reviewed by a government agency. Yes there was an occasional malpractice which was hastily dealt with and yes the hospital was sued during the 6 years I was there. But the overwhelming majority of medical and nursing related practitioners were extremely professional and supportive as we dealt with bringing this 100 year old big hospital into the 21st century. I was surprised to find patients who took advantage of the system too. One case that happened just before I took over was with a mother who presented with a pregnancy that was overdue and complicated. She demanded her doctor who lived away from the hospital attend her and in the delay the nurse attending saw we could lose the mother so exercising her judgment on behalf of the patient she delivered a baby which was mongoloid. The parents saw an opportunity to make money out of the situation, sued and got a $6 million settlement. It was supposed to be used to support the child for life in Australia. The parents took the baby to a village in Asia and left it with village people to care for, and used the money to set up a factory there for their own profit. I learned from that experience that there are faults on both side of the divide between patient and medical fraternity. Like you, I salute those in the medical profession who do things right. I’m aware of many dedicated village doctors in India who offer a life of service and do not make money like some of the medical people in cities like Mumbai. For a little bit of humour you may be interested to read one of my old blogs called BLOCK B. It was my personal experience in one of the cities of India.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. I was at great pains to protect their privacy in that blog so would have to respectfully decline to answer that. It was their charity ward where that humorous event took place and we received good attention when both my wife and I were admitted in their paid for wards. However I would not like a repeat of Block B ever again. lol

      Liked by 2 people

    1. Yeah,
      Out here, those questions arent even answerd properly.
      Doctors here behave like self proclaimed gods, nurses are hell rude.
      The patients near ones are already depressed, upon that they behave like theyre the only ones superior.
      Its getting worse.

      Liked by 2 people

  5. Hardi, thank you for your thoughtful writing about a very frightening topic. It seems to be prevalent anywhere in the world. Patients an families must ask questions and be alert to their own care even while under the care of doctors and hospitals.

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Recently I’ve come to know about such incidents in the newspaper….I don’t know what is the condition in other states of India, but the state of Government hospitals in West Bengal is inhuman..there are a few doctors who attend hundreds of patients everyday. Malpractice is a common affair not only in less-known nursing homes but also in reputed sophisticated hospitals…treatment has become a farce nowadays…

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: